AFL 23 provides a simulation of Australian Rules Football. Players directly control on-field actions, navigating bumps, executing tackles, and performing high-flying marks during matches. Beyond direct match participation, players manage their team roster, developing draftees and making tactical decisions on game day. These strategic choices aim to guide the team towards premiership success.

The game integrates commentary from Anthony Hudson, Jason Bennett, Kelli Underwood, Garry Lyon, and Daniel Harford. Extensive creation tools, known as the Academy Tools, enable players to design and share custom clubs, players, and stadiums. Authenticity is central, with all AFL and AFLW teams meticulously modelled. Over 1200 players are captured via photogrammetry, their individual skills and traits powered by Champion Data. This is a comprehensive Australian Rules Football simulation.